Death by worksheet
I write this as a frustrated parent watching her child shift between two entirely different worlds as if one bares no resemblance to the other. Those two worlds are home and school.
At home my son will build and play with lego, play make believe games with his sister, draw, ride his bike, play his PS3, play games on the internet and play intuitively with a plethora of different apps on mobile devices. When he doesn’t know a word he is reading or when he wants new words to use in his writing, he heads to the iPad dictionary and thesaurus apps without a second thought.
When he enters the school gates each day however, access to such interactive tools and activities, to which he is so familiar, are limited. In most cases they are replaced with worksheets and huge, heavy text books. Information is static and they are passive recipients.
This is not a personal gripe about the school he presently attends; great inroads are being made into using more technology in the classroom to enhance the great teaching and learning they already do. I am thankful for all their hard work but as an advocate for a 21st Century Education for today’s children, and of course an advocate for my own children and how they learn best, I cannot help but notice the discrepancy between his two worlds and wish that it wasn’t so. Understanding why it is so and arguments for change are a much bigger conversation for another time.
Every night when I unpack his backpack, I unload a heap of worksheets and tests he has fastidiously completed throughout the day and a list of homework tasks, most of which begin with ‘complete worksheet number XX’ or ‘read pages x -x and complete questions’. Now, I am not suggesting that there is no place for worksheets in his, or any other child’s education, but there has to be more correlation between their two lives. There are most certainly lots of fun activities going on his classroom, he loves the experiments and the projects and he has some great teachers, but he needs more. Recently he arrived home with a huge science text book, he had to read and absorb several pages of text and then regurgitate what he had learned by answering a set number of questions. I have to admit, we both struggled with the task! Being a visual learner, the pictures helped but compared to his everyday visually stimulating and interactive world outside of school, it wasn’t enough. His eyes glazed over and I could tell that not much was being absorbed; we had to figure out a way, a better way, for him to learn the content. What to do?
He then suggested searching for You Tube videos and using Brainpop.com to look up the topic. He was gone, rapidly online and researching his topic. Chuckling as he watched videos that explained the same content but with pictures and animation that brought it to life and made his learning relevant. We went back to the book, re-read part of the topic chapter and set about talking about the content and making connections between the two.
I realise that there is no doubt that this topic is personally relevant for me, having a child who finds reading large amounts of text a challenge, but I know he is not the only one. I also know that there are many too that would not have struggled with the text and that’s ok too. We could also review and discuss equity in relation to how much technology different children have exposure to at home, I understand that impacts things. However, I strongly believe that regardless of those facts, life outside of school for the majority of children today is full of visual and interactive stimulants everyday whether it’s TV, video games, dad’s smartphone or their own home computer, they want to be connected and their school life needs to reflect this fact. It’s their future.



Thanks for this post! Shared it on Google+. What a great visual representation of the student experience. Looks like busy work!
Thanks Twyla!
Dear Deb, this is the question I m asking myself and right now French education system which my kids integrated recently . Are we educating kids formthe future or are we stuck in the past, proud of it???? Why my kids spend hours to make HW wirh old dictionary when they go spontaneously on google? why to bring home tons of photocopies, while schoolmannounce proudly being green? There I’d definitely big reflexion on education that should be done… Thanks for sharing!!!
Hi Misa, you are right, big changes needed and it’s taking too long for most. At home, information is available, instant and in many different forms. School systems must allow the teachers the creative space to provide alternate learning opportunities for these kids and the training to help them do it.
Thanks
Deb
Hi Deb, A topical issue for me! I went to a school meeting last week on Maths and the use of an online application for homework. The school is using an application similar to ALex but geared towards the UK education system. When questioned why it was not used all the time instead of worksheets which come home weekly the teachers reply was that a large proportion of parents are ante doing online maths and that they wish to see a sheet of neatly completed sums because this is how their kids need to complete the work to pass exams for secondary schools and later complete exams. Following further debate the teacher agreed that the computer based maths was more student orientated and therefore could deliver better student focused learning but said that the staff cant dictate what the kids do but need to work in partnership with the parents. Hence using both methods worksheets and online systems. My thoughts are how do we educate parents of the benefits offered by interactive education and also increase the rate of change for assessment as that in the end is what make the difference. While exams depend on regurgitating information change will be slow.
Hi Dee,
This is such a far reaching conversation isn’t it? You’re right, parent education is most certainly key, raising awareness and understanding of the power of technology to make learning inclusive and relevant for the 21st Century.
I agree with the issue in relation to assessment and I appreciate the point these parents raise; it’s all very well changing the tools they use to learn in the classroom but assessment methods have to move with the times also. There has to be correlation between the two, we can’t teach and learn one way, and be assessed another……This has to be addressed and has to be a priority, these methods need to be changed to suit the world our children live and play in and the world they will come to work in in the future. Change is too slow coming.